There is a lot said about knitting as process. But I’m going to weigh in anyway. Personally, I’ve struggled a bit with this. Initially, I really needed a product with a defined use to justify buying wool and starting a project.
Then I started getting interested in lace. But I couldn’t think who I would make it for. I’m not terribly butch but I don’t wear much really frilly feminine stuff and lace seemed frilly and feminine to me. I also couldn’t imagine wearing a shawl. And although I’m a pretty good knitter (and really good at learning things from books and instructions), I was dithering about how complicated lace might be.
My first lace project was the Claddagh wrap by Alice Starmore. It is done in aran weight wool (I used Mission Falls) and the pattern is pretty easy to get the hang of so it goes pretty fast. I did it in a colour that would suit my MILs decor and gave it to her for her conservatory. She lives in the Lake District (in England) and the back wall of her conservatory is a dry stone wall so it is a bit drafty. Even if she wouldn’t use it, I figured some of her many guests might appreciate something warm around their shoulders. They use that conservatory all year for various social things including playing string quartets with friends.
Last summer, I decided to make Lucy Neatby’s Faroese Flower Shawl. In order to take the leap, I had to imagine who it would be for. I decided to knit it for my mother on the grounds that if she thought it was a bit old lady-ish, I could argue that she actually is an old lady (she will be 78 this month). But my main reason for doing it was to try a complicated lace pattern. I’d tried the doll size Faroese at Heartstrings to get a sense of the shaping. And the Flower Shawl was attractive because it was an all over lace with some variation (big and little flowers).
I didn’t tell my mom that I was making it. There were two reasons. One, I didn’t want her to tell me that it didn’t sound like her thing. Two, and probably more importantly, I didn’t want to feel under pressure to finish it. I figured that if I finished it by August, I’d give it to her for her birthday. If not, I’d give it to her for Xmas. Or the next birthday. I enjoyed the knitting of it so much that I gave it to her for her birthday last year. She loved it.
And it was the complicatedness of the knitting that I enjoyed. Having to follow the chart. Seeing how the marks on the page translated into ‘flowers’ in the lace. Learning to read the knitting. I also really like the shape but many of the Faroese patterns I see have substantial amounts of garter stitch in them. Boring to knit and not much to look at (though probably very practical). Maybe the Flower shawl isn’t very traditional but it was great fun to knit.
Since then I have done things like buy a skein of mohair from the sale bin at the LYS and make a simple shawl for myself. I wear it a lot in the winter when watching TV or when sitting around. You know those times when you are doing something relatively sedentary and the heating doesn’t quite feel like enough. The shawl makes a huge difference. So, I can now imagine myself wearing a shawl. And my 8 year old daughter also wants one. (That I’ll have to design myself, probably. Have to seen a pattern for a child-sized shawl?)
After the Faroese Flower Shawl, I started looking at other patterns and was really drawn to the Peacock Feathers shawl from Fiddlesticks. I thought about that off and on for a long time. Eventually I saw some nice fingering weight alpaca at Elann in a colour I liked and bought enough to do something like that. I ordered the pattern. And this spring I knit that shawl.
It is quite complicated. The pattern changes as the shawl gets bigger, partly mirroring the way that the peacock feathers are larger at the end of the tail than on the back of the peacock. I made beaded stitch markers to mark off the repeats so that the knitting of it was as pretty as the wearing of it. I ended up making a small diversion into making beaded stitch markers and sending some to friends. The shawl is huge but it didn’t really take that long to finish because I enjoyed it so much. It really was the process. The pattern was complicated enough that I had to follow the charts, mark off the repeats, count my stitches to make sure I hadn’t missed anything … but it was incredibly meditative to knit. After a while there were several repeats to a row so I didn’t need to keep looking at the chart all the way across.
When it was finished it was so big that I couldn’t block the whole thing on my queen sized bed. The tips were left unblocked (and later done with the iron — just holding it over the knitting and hitting the surge of steam button while stretching out the lace and trying not to burn my fingers). And it is really big on. But it is stunning. I’m now trying to find an occasion to wear it and something to wear with it. A very close friend is getting married in early November which might be a perfect occasion.
After this experience I just want to knit more lace. I’ve done a couple of scarves and recommend the summer issue of Vogue Knitting for a couple of patterns. I have a weird block about doing leaf lace in colours leaves don’t come in but I’m sure I will get over that sometime. I did an FBS though got somewhat frustrated that the central decrease in the basket is right slanting rather than centred. I gave the benefit of the doubt to the designer and assumed she intended it that way but wondered, all the same.
I have purchased both Folk Shawls and Best of Knitters Shawls and Scarves but am not finding myself drawn to many of the patterns. I have swatched a couple and find the shape of the motifs a bit off in some cases. Maybe it’ll take a particular yarn. I did do a smaller version of the Kimono Shawl from Folk Shawls in some Fleece Artist sock yarn. It is the same width as the pattern but just less than half as long. I’ve decided it is a baby blanket and given it to a pregnant friend (who thankfully doesn’t plan on pastel colours).
I’m having difficulty finding patterns I like though. ‘Easily memorized’ and ’suitable for the beginning lace knitter’ really put me off. I want to knit lace for the challenge and that meditative quality. This means I also tend to like things where the lace pattern changes as the shawl grows. Those patterns are harder to resize and, of course, I’m not one for using the recommended yarn. I think I could design something myself but designing takes a lot of time. And what I really want to do is knit, follow the chart, mark the repeats (with pretty markers), and watch the marks on the page get transformed into lace.
I have done a scarf designed by Sivia Harding that was suitably complicated and am tempted to do a second one (shorter) with the yarn left over. The only thing holding me back is the worry that it will be too short to be useful. I knit lace for the process but the product still needs to have some use, it seems.
I used the search feature on Elann yesterday to find interesting shawl and scarf patterns and ended up order just under $50 worth. Some of the more complicated ones are trying a bit too hard to be representational which was putting me of somewhat. Funny, since I liked both the flowers and the peacock feathers so much. I also just don’t get square or round shawls. Why do I want to knit something that has to be folded in half? I understand the limitations of the triangle but would like to see more in the faroese style, perhaps.
If you have any interesting lace patterns that you might recommend, let me know. I have about 2000 yards of some lace/fingering weight alpaca and silk I picked up in Prince Edward County that I intend to use for that purpose. I’m also debating whether the Fleece Artist worsted weight (500 yards) I picked up might make a nice shawl. Imagining lace in heavier yarns is harder but then I did that Claddagh wrap in aran weight.
Anything that would use up about 175 yards of lace weight cashmere would also be welcome. Or, if you have a slender neck and live somewhere where a scarf would be mainly decorative (and might not need to wrap around your neck), let me know. I could trade a lovely red cashmere beaded lace scarf for something….